Get started selling products online with our free downloadable workbook.
The email you entered is invalid.
Thank you for subscribing.
By entering your email, you indicate that you have read and understood our Privacy Policy and agree to receive marketing from Squarespace.
Picture this: You're walking down a busy street looking for a place to eat lunch. There are two restaurants side by side—one is empty, while the other has a line out the door. Which one would you choose? If you're like most people, you'd probably join the line, trusting that all those other diners know something you don't.
This is social proof in action, and it's one of the most powerful tools you can use to grow your business, whether you're selling jewelry, offering consulting services, or teaching online courses.
Understanding social proof: More than following the crowd
At its core, social proof is a psychological phenomenon that refers to people looking to the actions of others to determine their own behavior. It's the digital equivalent of that busy restaurant: When we see other people, especially people we're familiar with, vouching for a product or service, we're more likely to trust and choose it ourselves.
But social proof isn't just about having a crowd of customers. It's about building trust through authentic validation from real people who have actually experienced your business. As consumers become more skeptical of traditional advertising, social proof has become an essential foundation for business growth.
Why social proof matters for your business
More than ever, consumers are saying that online reviews impact their purchasing decisions. In recent research, almost 70% of online shoppers read between one and six reviews before buying. But the benefits of social proof go beyond just influencing purchases.
Quickly building credibility
Social proof builds credibility more quickly than traditional marketing does. While advertisements tell customers why they should trust you, social proof shows them why others already do.
When real customers share their positive experiences, it creates instant credibility that would otherwise take longer to build through traditional marketing alone. This third-party validation carries more weight than any self-promotional content you could create.
Authentically creating trust
Unlike traditional marketing messages—which can sometimes feel pushy or too promotional—social proof feels authentic because it comes from real people and genuine experiences. When potential customers see other people sharing honest feedback, it creates a natural trust that doesn’t trigger the skepticism that’s often associated with advertising.
Because of how many ads we all see every day, potential customers and clients also may tune out traditional marketing. Promotion that feels organic in regular content may get more views.
Creating a vision for customers
Social proof helps customers envision themselves using your product or service. Through customer stories, reviews and user-generated content, prospective customers can see how people are benefitting from what you’re offering.
Whether this is through someone sharing a photo wearing your clothing or a testimonial about how your service helped someone succeed, this ultimately makes it easier for them to imagine the specific ways your product or service could fit into their own lives.
Reducing perceived risk
Making a purchase, especially from a business that is new or unfamiliar for someone, always carries some risk. Social proof acts as a risk reducer by showing that other people have already taken the leap and had a positive experience.
Organic word-of-mouth marketing
Strong social proof content can create a snowball effect. When satisfied customers share their experience, they influence potential buyers and inspire other customers to share their own positive feedback. This can create a self-sustaining cycle of authentic recommendations that can significantly expand your reach without additional marketing spend.
Types of social proof that can power your business
1. Customer reviews and testimonials
Customer reviews and testimonials are the most common, powerful, and organic form of social proof. These can range from simple star ratings to detailed accounts of customer experiences. What makes them effective is their authenticity—real people sharing real experiences.
You can build requests for reviews or testimonials into your customer communication flows. For example, you can set up an automated email requesting a review one week after someone places an order. Or send a feedback form that includes a testimonial request to clients after completing a project with them.
2. Expert endorsements
When industry leaders or recognized experts in your field validate your business, it carries significant weight for both current and potential customers. This could be as simple as a quote from an expert using your product or as formal as a professional certification.
This is an area where networking with peers in your industry or related ones is helpful. For example, a photographer might endorse the work of a makeup artist in public posts or recommend them to others and vice versa. Or a small jewelry business might partner with a small-batch bakery or candle business, an implied endorsement from each brand to its customers.
3. User-generated content
Photos, videos, or stories created by your customers can help show your product or service in action. This type of social proof is particularly powerful because it shows authentic, real-world applications of what you offer, and it helps potential customers think about how they would use your product or service.
Ideally, this will happen organically and you can reshare this content on your own channels with permission. But you can also encourage people to post user-generated content on your social media or in post-purchase and post-service messages.
4. Social media engagement
On social media, likes, shares, comments, and follows are quick visual indicators of the popularity and reliability of your business. While this measurement of social proof is not as detailed as reviews, social media engagement provides instant validation to potential customers.
Put yourself in a customer’s shoes: If you’re browsing a business you’ve never heard of before, you might be less comfortable buying from one that has a small handful of followers, few posts on their account, and few likes or comments on their content. Every business starts from scratch, but it’s worth encouraging your supporters to follow and engage to get a head start.
5. Case studies
Having detailed examples of how your product or service helped solve specific customer problems is a great way to integrate social proof into your business. Case studies are particularly effective for service providers or B2B businesses.
This is a good use case for a blog or short case study in client proposals. On your blog, you can recap the experience of working with a client or another business and the results you were able to garner for them. A shorter version of this can go into your proposal template. For example, a nutritionist can detail a client’s goals, the custom fitness and diet plan created to meet them, and the results over time.
How to generate authentic social proof
When it comes to social proof that resonates, the key word is authentic. Manufactured social proof can backfire, ultimately damaging your reputation and trust. Here's how to encourage genuine social proof.
Make it easy. This includes clear calls-to-action for reviews, providing links to multiple platforms for feedback, using automated follow-up emails to request reviews and creating shareable moments in the customer experience.
Timing is everything. Ask for feedback when customers are most satisfied, follow-up within a day or two after positive customer interactions and create timely opportunities for sharing their experiences.
Value is a priority. Focus on delivering exceptional service, solve problems proactively, and make sure the experiences you’re creating for customers are valuable and worth talking about.
Engage authentically. Respond to both negative and positive reviews, share customer success stories, and make an effort to create a real community around your brand.
Common pitfalls to avoid
Ultimately, good social proof is about tapping into the one-on-one human connection between you and your customers or clients. That means it’s best to avoid anything that feels counter to forming a genuine relationship.
Using fake reviews: Never create or purchase fake reviews. Besides being unethical, customers can catch on to it. Plus, doing this can damage your reputation.
Overemphasizing quantity: Quality over quantity, always. Focus on quality testimonials that tell a story rather than just collecting large numbers of basic reviews.
Ignoring negative feedback: Instead of ignoring negative feedback from customers, use it as an opportunity to demonstrate your commitment to customer satisfaction.
Neglecting updates: Be sure to regularly refresh your social proof to keep it current and relevant.
Implementing social proof in your marketing
Once you've collected social proof, use it strategically. Place content in places where potential customers and clients are likely to spend time evaluating your business.
On your website
Feature customer and client testimonials on your homepage.
Create a dedicated reviews or case studies page on your website.
Include high-quality customer photos and stories.
Display trust badges and certifications, if you have them.
In your marketing materials
Include customer quotes in newsletters and email blasts.
Share user-generated content on social media.
Feature your business case studies in blog posts.
Add testimonials to sales materials, like client proposals.
Building long-term success with social proof
Remember that social proof is not a one-time effort, but rather an ongoing process of building and maintaining trust with your current and potential clients and customers. With that in mind, if you focus on creating genuine connections and exceptional experiences, the social proof will follow naturally.
Start small—perhaps with a simple request for reviews from your most satisfied customers—and gradually build up a more robust social proof strategy. As you collect more positive feedback and testimonials, you'll create a virtuous cycle where social proof helps you attract more customers, who in turn generate more social proof.
The most successful businesses don't just collect social proof—they build their entire customer experience around creating moments worth talking about. When you focus on delivering value and building relationships, social proof becomes not just a marketing tactic, but a natural byproduct of running a business that people love.